|
Tiny Targets of the Small
Screen
-
Akhila Sivadas and Shailaja Bajpai -
A study
conducted by the Centre for Advocacy and Research for UNESCO in 1998
accuses the
idiot box of bombarding young minds with all kinds of violent images,cutting
across channels,programmes and viewing times.
Introduction
The morning study was conducted
during the week 24th August-2nd September 1998, across 5 channels, DDI,
DD2, Zee, Sony, Star Plus.
who are sponsoring the serials.
Objective
Study
1. To quantify the extent of violence
in drama serials across five channels.
2. To identify the nature and types
of violence being depicted.
3. To identify the audiences targetted-Particularly
children-by such serials and by the advertisers who are sponsoring the
serials.
Drama serials of different genres
across 5 channels were selected-
-
Daily soaps/drama serials/suspense horror
in the prime time evening and afternoon bands as well as selected news
items.
-
In all, 56 hours 20 minutes were monitored,
among them 81 serial episodes, 6 news bulletins and two current affairs
programmes, and one documentary
-
Zee, Star Plus and DDI have received
a higher degree of representation because of the greater concentration
of serials in the prime time and afternoon transmission.
Quantitative
Findings
In all, there were 759 distinct
acts of violence across the 5 channels over a period of nine days.
In proportion to the hours monitored
Zee has the highest acts of violence and DD1 had the lowest
| Channels |
Acts |
| Zee |
365 |
| Star |
188 |
| DD2 |
80 |
| Sony |
64 |
| DD1 |
62 |
Types of
Violence
-
In all 59 types of violence, both audio
and visual, both physical and psychological were identified. Of these threats,
slapping, screaming, shooting, assaulting, expletives, pushing, clobbering,
stabbing, mental torture, eerie soundtracks, threatening music are extremely
prominent. These categories of violence account for over 50 per cent of
the total acts depicted. Hence much of the violence is explicit and graphic.
-
Some depictions of violence are unnecessarily
lengthy.
-
Nearly one-third of the depictions (283
acts out of a total of 759 acts) appeared in 25 per cent or 21 out of 81
episodes monitored. These 21 episodes were in the genre of horror/ murder/
mystery/ suspense thrillers.
-
Some of these serials are often the
most violent or disturbing - especially for children. For example: X-Zone
and Anhonee (Zee) together had 118 or 53 and 65 acts of violence respectively;
Aahat (Sony) had 13 acts of violence; Kohra (STAR Plus) had 30 acts of
violence in a single episode
The remaining two-third acts are depicted
in the 60 episodes of drama serials monitored. In fact, family drama serials
or programmes specifically targetting children are no less violent.
In a single episode of the serial
Gumraah there were 32 acts, while there were 17 acts of violence in the
child-specific Shaktimaan.
Areas of
Concern
Within the larger question of the
depiction of violence, there were specific areas of concern. These include:Programme
schedules, Violent promos, Treatment and depiction,Representation of child
and gender-based violence,Glorification of violence, and the role of companies
and sponsors specialising in children's products supporting such programmes.
Programme
Schedule
Channel-specific
concentration
On different channels, we found that
nbsp; specific days were more prone to violence than other days.
For example, Tuesday on Sony Entertainment, Monday on Star Plus and Thursday
and Sunday on Zee TV Network accounted for 35 per cent, 40 per cent and
over 50 per cent, respectively, of the total acts of violence on the channel
during the monitoring period.
Time-slot cocentration
Inter-channel rivalary and competition
has led to a simultaneous scheduling of programme with high incidence of
violence. These prime time serials in the 9.00 p.m. and 9.30 are often
the most violent and disturbing kind-espetially for children.
Below is a table with a few examples
of violent programmes across channels in the same time zones or succeeding
each other.
| DAY |
TIME |
PROGRAMME |
CHANNEL |
| Tue |
9.00 pm. |
Raja Aur
Rancho
Shapath
Alpviram |
DD2
Zee
Sony |
| Wed. |
9.30 pm. |
Who
CID |
Zee
Sony |
| Thu |
9.00 pm. |
Sea-Hawks
X-Zone |
DD2
Zee |
| 9.30 pm |
Aahat |
Sony |
| 10.00 Pm. |
Bhanwar |
Sony |
Repeats
Even when programmes or films are
telecast late at night, perhaps in an efforts to reduce children's access
to them, they are repeated in the afternoon and early evenings. Satellite
and cable TV channels repeat many violent programmes and films in the afternoons
and early evenings. Fo0r instance, India's Most Wanted and Woh have repeat
telecast at 4p.m., and 4.30 pm., Bhanwar is repeated at noon and the next
afternoon in 3 pm. slot.
Violent
Promos
Promos for all types of programmes-comedies,
drama serials, films and even the news-carry very violent scenes in the
belief that this is a hook for the viewer. Violence, more than any other
ingredient is being used to sell and promote programmes. The promos of
a comedy such as Tu Tu Main Main, or a serial such as Chattan are more
violent that the programmes themselves.
Treatment
And Depiction
Definition
of Violence
The fundamental defination of violence
places emphasis on a number of elements including intention to harm/
scare, the physical or mental nature
of the harm and the involvement of animate beings. To quote from the National
Television Survey of America: "Any overt depiction of a credible threat
of physical (and even psychological) harm or the actual use of forces intended
to harm an animate being or group of beings."
1. Horror
Shows
There is conclusive evidence, tacitly
accepted by the industry, that children watch prime time evening television.
Television viewing in India is still considered a family affair and TV
serials are produced for and aimed at the entire family. As children grow
older, they tend to watch more adult programming. Thus children watch programmes
in the 7.30 p.m.-10 p.m. belt and also beyond that. They watch horror shows
and suspense serials (sometimes, despite strong parental disapproval).
The issue of violence becomes critical
because some of them go beyond the internationally acceptable limits of
5 to 6 acts of physical violence in a half-an-hour episode. While some
reach figures ranging from 22 to 24 even serials targetted at children
are not made an exception to this rule. 7 to 12 acts of violence exist
even in them and they often include extreme acts such as murder, bombing
and burning. (Anhonee, X-Zone, Shaktimaan and Raja Aur Rancho)
Moreover, this excess depiction of
physical acts of violence does not deter them from taking recourse to other
categories of violence. Very often, they co-exist with other forms of violence
such as verbal and bizarre sound effects which include music and occasionally
even psychological violence.
Certain serials take great care to
avoid acts of physical violence but they repeatedly used eerie sound tracks,
occasional hallucinations, nightmares, paranoia to build an atmosphere
of terror.
Recognising its implications, they
are even telecasting a warning note on superstition and a belief in the
paranormal are being telecast. The warning before Aahat for example states:
"these stories are based on fantasy and are meant to entertain only.''
However, it was found that episodes dealing with superstition were not
depicted as fantasy at all. The stories were often situated in perfectly
realistic and every day situations and more importantly, based upon actual
beliefs.
If you examine the justification
or reason of violence, we find that psychopathic behaviour accounts for
percentages as high as 26% to 50% on a given day in a specific channel
and within one episode of a programme can be even more than 50%. Other
reasons are police interrogation, blackmail, revenge Rivalry, provoking
aggression, dealing of the underworld, intergenerational conflict.
These serials are being telecast
at family viewing times.
Hooking child-viewer
to violence or horror in serials.
-
It is quite clear that horror shows
and crime series target the child viewer. Audience rating in the 6-4 years
age group indicate that Aahat, Anhonee, Bhanwar, India’s Most Wanted, X-Zone
are in the top ten programmes watched by children in the last 2 months.
-
The UNESCO report found that children
admire superheroes. The serial Shaktimaaan is about a superhero who is
capable of extraordinary physical feats. It is very popular with child
viewers who are attracted by Shaktimaan’s exploits. Children tend to imitate
such exploits and though there is a warning by the star of the serial against
such imitation, there is a warning by the star of the serial against such
imitations, there have been instances when children have tried and got
hurt imitating Shaktimaaan.
Last month, the Times of India reported
the case of a body who had seriously injured himself imitating Shaktimaan.
Disclaimers in such cases are not always enough.
The nature of the violence in a serial
such as this is also manifold-as mentioned earlier, in one episode of Shaktimaan,
there were 17 acts of violence in approximately 25 minutes. These included
assaulting, slapping, punching, shooting, and strangulating, burning, pushing,
stabbing as well as grotesque representations, bodily transformations and
supernatural occurrences.
-
In both Who and Aur Rancho, the child
viewers is being hooked to the serial by elements, which will appeal to
children: i.e., the clown or joker in Who, and the monkey in Raja Aur Rancho.
Continue |